Jeffrey Parks MD FACS
  • Home
  • About
  • Contact
  • Blog
  • Videos
  • Forms
  • Podcasts

"Just" a General Surgeon

3/31/2015

3 Comments

 
A few months ago, I was seeing an elderly man in the hospital about a sigmoid mass seen on his colonoscopy that day.  He had presented to the hospital with fatigue and anemia and the long meandering workup eventually zeroed in on this malignant appearing mass as the source.  His daughter was in the room while I discussed the results, the likely diagnosis, treatment options, and anticipated complications.  She was very engaged with the conversation and seemed highly informed.  The questions she asked were advanced and sophisticated--- part Google search, part higher education background.  Her mien was that of an eager person interviewing for a job she really really wanted.  I liked her. She was earnest and serious about the situation at hand.  She  obviously loved her father.  He seemed to defer much of the decision making process to her.  He kept looking over at her with a faintly bemused expression.  I was recommending surgery and he just smiled.  What do you think, sweetie?  Should I get this surgery? He looked like a man who would do whatever she said.  He looked tired and worn down and it didn't matter about the cancer, all that mattered was doing what his daughter wanted.  His eyes gleamed when he looked over at her.  

I answered several of a series of her questions about the surgery proposed.  Laparoscopy vs open.  Potential complications.  Expected recovery time.  Need for radiation or chemotherapy.  We went through it all, thoroughly.  I was in there a good 45 minutes.  It seemed she was coming around to the idea of having her father cut open, the tumor extracted.  And then she said something that put me on my heels. 

"Now....you're just a general surgeon, right?  Will you be contacting a colon specialist to evaluate Dad for surgery?"  

I just sort of stood there for a second or two, bewildered.   But because this is not the first time someone has asked me this question over the years I quickly gathered myself.  Before, I may have answered defensively.  But not this day.  I told her:

"Mrs Smith, I am indeed a general surgeon.  And I appreciate your interest your father's care.  Your love for him could not be more apparent.  I assure you, that the surgical procedure I described for you falls well within the scope of my normal practice.  I perform a lot of surgery for colon cancer and diverticulitis.  And I think my results stack up with anyone around.  That being said, I understand where you're coming from.  There are some surgeons who do a fellowship in colorectal surgery after general surgery training.  Those that do tend to make that an exclusive focus of their practice.  I know several terrific ones here in town.  I could connect you with one of them if that is your preference.  I also would be happy to take care of your father's needs myself.  You would get my best. "

She ended up staying at our hospital.  The surgery went well and her father had a good outcome.  I am a general surgeon and I have always taken great pride in that identity.  Some days I have five hernias on the schedule.  This past weekend I took out four gallbladders and drained a breast abscess.  I see women with abnormal mammograms.   I get IV access and manage patients in the ICU.   I correct large diaphragmatic hernias.   I drain butt pus.  I  whack out rotten appendices.  I biopsy masses and see consults in the ER.  I cover trauma call and take out smashed spleens.  I operate early mornings and late at night.  It is the life I have chosen.  I knew what I was getting into.  

But I have grown to wonder if the term "general surgeon" means what it used to mean.  It started years ago when components of the general surgery repertoire began to fragment and separate from the main body.  In the late 90's you were just as likely to have a general surgeon perform your carotid endarterectomy as a fellowship trained vascular surgeon.  Nowadays, such a thought is risible.  Vascular surgery itself has sort of branched off into its own universe, leaving general surgery far behind.  Similarly, general surgeons have ceded much territory in the realm of endoscopy.  In many small towns and rural settings, most of the colonoscopies may be done by a general surgeon, but it's rare in a larger city.  Thyroidectomies are now being done by "endocrine surgeons".  Breast lumpectomies get referred exclusively to "breast surgeons".  Laparoscopic hernia cases get sent to the "minimally invasive fellowship trained" guy at the main campus.   Melanoma goes to surgical oncologists or "Moh's dermatology surgeons".    

In addition to the fragmentation of surgical practice into various specialties and sub specialties, alterations in surgical residency training programs have had unintended, undesirable consequences.  The 80 hour work week restrictions, implemented over the course of 2004-2008  have led to a scenario where graduating chief residents are unfit for independent clinical practice.  They haven't done enough surgery.  They simply haven't spent enough time in the hospital.  To wit:
  • 80% of graduating surgical residents go on to do a fellowship
  • 25% of senior residents report feeling unprepared for independent practice
  • Surgical fellowship program directors note that 30% of fellows were not prepared for operative cases and 2/3 could not work unsupervised for extended periods
  • Oral board exam failure rates have increased from 15% to 25% since work hour reform was implemented  
The American College of Surgeons is very much aware of this burgeoning crisis and has taken steps to try and rectify matters.  One idea is the concept of Transition to Practice (TTP) program.  In this paradigm, graduating senior residents would spend a year as "apprentice surgeons" under the tutelage of some older, experienced surgeon with a broad practice scope.  The hope is that this would help younger surgeons gradually grow more comfortable in a role as an independent practitioner rather than suddenly being thrust into the world without the necessary training or confidence.  Further, since so many surgeons do a fellowship simply because they feel unprepared for an independent career otherwise, it is hoped that the TTP program will incentivize more graduating residents to pursue careers in general surgery.  The impending shortage of general surgeons, especially in rural areas, would stand to be corrected by such an outcome.  Mid sized cities could also stand to use a few more general surgeons--- and a few less hepatobiliary specialists sitting around waiting for the rare big cases.  

I consider myself lucky.  I trained at a busy residency program in Chicago and I completed most of my training before the work hour reforms kicked in.  I graduated with a certain confidence that I would be able to step into a general surgery practice on day one.  For me, there was nothing else to aspire to than to be a general surgeon.  But with the way the training has evolved over the past 10-15 years I ought not be surprised when a patient asks me why I am not more. Perception is everything.  For some reason, the idea of a generalist has become a derisive term.  It wasn't always that way.  I see myself as the last of a dying breed.  I am a general surgeon.  There is no shame in that....       
3 Comments
JT
3/31/2015 11:58:11 am

I definitely see the fault with specialties and sub specialties and am experiencing frustration for it. My husband and I moved from Shreveport Louisiana to Houston TX because I couldn't get an answer for a problem I was having. Turned out to be Haishimoto's disease. Last spring I began to get pain and stiffness in my hands that has spread to my feet and neck. I was referred to a rheumatologist. Diag was inflammatory arthritis. My C-reactive protein was 16 in October and 1 in February. It fluctuates. However, my platelet count is always borderline to high which still suggests inflammation. A few months ago, I started getting weird cuts or fissures on both perineum and labia. So far my gyn is unable to find a cause or provide much relief and has referred me to a "guru" that has no openings until May. I developed a very small hemorrhoid about 6 years ago and I've noticed that it seems to flare when these cuts are present. I get a reprieve but usually not for long. I tried searching these 2 symptoms together and landed on your Buckeye blog. I'm used to having weird things manifest and I'm used to having to dig for information in order to educate myself. Right now, I'm not sure where to look. It doesn't quite align with the usual suspects and I'm thinking it's another autoimmune curve ball. I'm a 35 year old female, married 10 yrs, no kids, teacher. Not sure if these demographics are helpful. Thank you.

Reply
Lesley Barron link
4/4/2015 12:24:50 pm

Could not agree with you more! See my blog. Patients won't come see me for breast issues because I am not a breast surgeon. I am pretty sure medicine in the coming years will see the problem with siloing of skills and come back to wanting generalists.

Reply
Marty Tousley @GriefHealing link
5/3/2015 10:40:43 am

Thank you for writing this, and I agree with you completely. My father was a general surgeon, highly regarded by his colleagues and his patients, and one of the finest doctors I've ever known. If he were alive today, I shudder to think how he would react to what has become of our "modern" health care system and its fragmented approach to total patient care. Blessings to you for being "just" a general surgeon, and a proud one at that. ♥

Reply

Your comment will be posted after it is approved.


Leave a Reply.

    Author

    Jeffrey C. Parks MD, FACS

    Archives

    December 2015
    October 2015
    July 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    February 2015
    January 2015

    Categories

    All
    Case Study
    General Surgery
    Healthcare Reform
    Surgery News

    RSS Feed

    RSS Feed

Proudly powered by Weebly